Welcome to the IKCEST
Russian president threatens criminal penalties for space officials; where do you stand on this?

Russian president, Dmitry Medevedev, announced that following the disaster with the Phobos-Grunt mission, which was headed for one of Mars’ moons but got stranded on Earth’s orbit, officials should be punished for recent failures in the country’s space program, which are affecting indirectly the entire country.

Speaking to Russian journalists on Saturday, he stated that these mistakes dealt a “serious blow to our competitiveness”, and they should be punished disciplinary, financially, and even criminally.

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive our new book for FREE
Join 50,000+ subscribers vaccinated against pseudoscience
Download NOW
By subscribing you agree to our Privacy Policy. Give it a try, you can unsubscribe anytime.

“This is not a fatal blow, but it does mean that we are going to have to make a thorough examination of the situation and punish those responsible,” Medvedev said.

However, he said this mustn’t be a violent action, like the USSR old days.

“I am not talking about putting anyone up against the wall, as during Stalin’s years, of course, but we can use money as a punishment, get back from them the funds we put into them, or, in cases where clear responsibility is established, disciplinary or criminal liability might need to be considered,” Medvedev said.

So where do you stand on this? If people responsible for this mistake are found, what should be the punishment ? Should it be criminal ? Can you really hold a scientist criminally responsible for being wrong? But then again, they literally threw over $60 million into outer space. What’s your opinion?

Original Text (This is the original text for your reference.)

Russian president, Dmitry Medevedev, announced that following the disaster with the Phobos-Grunt mission, which was headed for one of Mars’ moons but got stranded on Earth’s orbit, officials should be punished for recent failures in the country’s space program, which are affecting indirectly the entire country.

Speaking to Russian journalists on Saturday, he stated that these mistakes dealt a “serious blow to our competitiveness”, and they should be punished disciplinary, financially, and even criminally.

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive our new book for FREE
Join 50,000+ subscribers vaccinated against pseudoscience
Download NOW
By subscribing you agree to our Privacy Policy. Give it a try, you can unsubscribe anytime.

“This is not a fatal blow, but it does mean that we are going to have to make a thorough examination of the situation and punish those responsible,” Medvedev said.

However, he said this mustn’t be a violent action, like the USSR old days.

“I am not talking about putting anyone up against the wall, as during Stalin’s years, of course, but we can use money as a punishment, get back from them the funds we put into them, or, in cases where clear responsibility is established, disciplinary or criminal liability might need to be considered,” Medvedev said.

So where do you stand on this? If people responsible for this mistake are found, what should be the punishment ? Should it be criminal ? Can you really hold a scientist criminally responsible for being wrong? But then again, they literally threw over $60 million into outer space. What’s your opinion?

Comments

    Something to say?

    Log in or Sign up for free

    Disclaimer: The translated content is provided by third-party translation service providers, and IKCEST shall not assume any responsibility for the accuracy and legality of the content.
    Translate engine
    Article's language
    English
    中文
    Pусск
    Français
    Español
    العربية
    Português
    Kikongo
    Dutch
    kiswahili
    هَوُسَ
    IsiZulu
    Action
    Related

    Report

    Select your report category*



    Reason*



    By pressing send, your feedback will be used to improve IKCEST. Your privacy will be protected.

    Submit
    Cancel